Kyler Murray vs Baker Mayfield

Kyler Murray vs Baker Mayfield

In Superflex dynasty, Kyler Murray is barely ahead, so it's basically a coin flip (2,133 vs 2,133). So it depends on your team: contenders should lean Baker Mayfield, rebuilders Kyler Murray. Kyler Murray is 2 years younger, which matters more the longer your window is. Updated November 18, 2026.

Run this trade in the calculatorAnalyze your Sleeper league
Kyler MurrayBaker Mayfield
Dynasty Superflex2,133 QB212,133 QB22
Dynasty 1QB546 QB30809 QB23
Redraft (rest of season)—91 QB25
Age29.331.6
30-day value trend-35%-8%
Playoff schedule (wks 15-17, 1st = easiest)1st of 3217th of 32
VerdictBuyHold

Kyler Murray: Buy

Experts rank him above his trade price; his value is down 35% in 30 days.

Baker Mayfield: Hold

His trade price, trend and outlook are all in line, so there's no edge either way: keep him unless a trade clearly upgrades your lineup.

More comparisons: Kyler Murray vs Bryce Young, Baker Mayfield vs Cam Ward.

FAQ

Who is better in dynasty, Kyler Murray or Baker Mayfield?

In Superflex dynasty, Kyler Murray is barely ahead, so it's basically a coin flip (2,133 vs 2,133). Kyler Murray is 2 years younger, which matters more the longer your window is.

Who should I start or trade for this season, Kyler Murray or Baker Mayfield?

See the redraft row above.

Is Kyler Murray for Baker Mayfield a fair trade?

Yes, it's close to even in Superflex dynasty value. Check it in the trade calculator with your league's format.