Caleb Williams vs Patrick Mahomes

Caleb Williams vs Patrick Mahomes

In Superflex dynasty, Caleb Williams has a slight edge (8,847 vs 7,748). For the rest of this season, Caleb Williams is worth more (2,431 vs 2,427). Caleb Williams is 6 years younger, which matters more the longer your window is. Updated November 18, 2026.

Run this trade in the calculatorAnalyze your Sleeper league
Caleb WilliamsPatrick Mahomes
Dynasty Superflex8,847 QB37,748 QB4
Dynasty 1QB4,062 QB43,777 QB5
Redraft (rest of season)2,431 QB52,427 QB6
Age25.031.2
30-day value trend+8%-1%
Playoff schedule (wks 15-17, 1st = easiest)14th of 3215th of 32
VerdictHoldHold

Caleb Williams: Hold

At 25, he has years left before the usual QB decline.

Patrick Mahomes: Hold

His trade price, trend and outlook are all in line, so there's no edge either way: keep him unless a trade clearly upgrades your lineup.

More comparisons: Caleb Williams vs Joe Burrow, Patrick Mahomes vs Lamar Jackson.

FAQ

Who is better in dynasty, Caleb Williams or Patrick Mahomes?

In Superflex dynasty, Caleb Williams has a slight edge (8,847 vs 7,748). Caleb Williams is 6 years younger, which matters more the longer your window is.

Who should I start or trade for this season, Caleb Williams or Patrick Mahomes?

For the rest of this season, Caleb Williams is worth more (2,431 vs 2,427).

Is Caleb Williams for Patrick Mahomes a fair trade?

Not quite: Caleb Williams is worth about 12% more in Superflex dynasty, so the other side should add a little. Check it in the trade calculator with your league's format.